You can throw the same virus at your innate immune system and it will not remember it. I noted then that there was no evidence that mass vaccination with MMR had produced variants of the measles vaccine resistant to the immunity produced by the vaccine, just as I note now that there is as yet no evidence that SARS-CoV-2 variants are resistant to the immunity produced by current COVID-19 vaccines. Some of these copies may by chance have the right kinds of errors in their genetic code to become variants of concern, although the mutation rate of this coronavirus is quite low. Statement by Geert Vanden Bossche, DMV, PhD, independent virologist and vaccine expert, formerly employed at GAVI and The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundaton. _). Exactly. Highlighting the principle of using a prophylactic vaccine in the midst of a pandemic. A recent review article suggests that immune escape by variants of SARS-CoV-2 is a possibility, but one that hasnt been definitively observed or demonstrated yet: So is there cause for concern? Reading the letter, what it reminded me, more than anything else, is an article that Andrew Wakefield wrote about the MMR vaccine and measles, published a few months before the pandemic hit. Buy The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic by Vanden Bossche MD Phd, Geert (ISBN: 9781956257809) from Amazon's Book Store. There is always concern that a virus or bacteria can mutate to a form such that the antibodies produced by a vaccine against it no longer bind to it, so that the vaccine-induced immune response no longer kills or neutralizes the pathogen. The latest example of this phenomenon comes in the form of Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche, who recently published an alarming manifesto. FDA: Vaccines Don't Have To Prevent Infection Or Transmission And if you have been at this for a while, like Dr. David Gorski who has followed and denounced the anti-vaccination movement since time immemorial, you may even pick up on similarities with the disgraced Andrew Wakefield. To all authorities, scientists and experts around the world, to whom this concerns: the entire world population. It is precisely this type of highly specific, high affinity Abs that current Covid-19 vaccines are inducing. ES. Please read and share: https://t.co/0Fupw9JInP #COVID19 pic.twitter.com/I24mSjpVKM, Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 6, 2021. . The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organizations, institutions, and industries lacking an understanding of this complex environment have turned a natural viral pandemic into one of disastrous immune escape. Published: 23 Mar 2021. After all, as Nirenberg and the review article I quoted above note, while it is true that variants of concern demonstrate reduced antibody neutralization, we do not as yet have an absolute correlate regarding how high an antibody level is required to be protective, making the practical meaning of this observation difficult to determine. The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic : Vanden Bossche MD Phd, Geert However, NK cell-based vaccines will primarily enable our natural immunity to be better prepared (memory!) Mass Vaccination in a Pandemic - Benefits versus Risks: Interview with Geert Vanden Bossche Vejon Health 46.7K subscribers 1.5M views 1 year ago Highlighting the principle of using a. by Geert Vanden Bossche, an independent virologist and self-described vaccine expert, attacking my letter. People who have been infected with SARS-CoV-2 seem . The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organizations, institutions, and industries . Variants are "a thing to keep an eye on," Saad Omer, an epidemiologist who serves as director of the Yale Institute for Global Health, told us in a phone interview. Vanden Bossche is using an eerily similar argument about COVID-19 vaccines and SARS-CoV-2, he wrote for the blog Science-Based Medicine, to the one used by Wakefield about [the measles-mumps-rubella] vaccine and measles. Geert Vanden Bossche is a scientist who published an open letter warning of global catastrophe due to deadly variants of COVID-19 selected for by mass vaccination. With antibiotic use, the bacteria that have developed a mutation or acquired a gene that gives them protection from the antibiotic will escape death and soon become the dominant strain. And its true. Vanden Bossche presented his ideas to the public in a series of open letters or powerpoint presentations on his personal website. untested waters given that widespread use of low-effectiveness vaccines did not exist in humans prior to the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020. Come to think of it, the similarities between Dr. Vanden Bossche and Andrew Wakefield strike me as stronger than ever now, given that, as well documented by Brian Deer, Wakefield basically published his fraudulent science to support the claim that the MMR vaccine causes autism in order to make a market for his own single vaccine against the measles. As I go through Dr. Vanden Bossches open letter, Ill point out the similarities, while also noting differences when they occur. Hes also started making rounds on the podcast/vlog interview circuit: You can watch yesterday's interview with Philip McMillan here: https://t.co/sx9fxpsyHg Thanks for all your support, we will need it. While scientists dont yet know exactly what levels of antibodies are needed to ward off disease, the approved vaccines do elicit the production of neutralizing antibodies. Page Flip is a new way to explore your books without losing your place. VERDICT. So-called leaky vaccines are vaccines that prevent disease, but do not appreciably slow transmission of the pathogen. Mass vaccination during pandemic historical blunder: Nobel laureate Vanden Bossche's argument, however, basically boils down to the idea that current COVID-19 vaccines, in conjunction with other preventive measures, are making the pandemic exponentially worse by breeding infectious variants. If Dr. Bossche fears the current vaccines so much, what is his solution? Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche, DMV, Ph.D., has nothing against vaccines. . Vaccines can put a stop to that. This is a very confused argument. It looks like WhatsApp is not installed on your phone. Former Virologist warns HALT ALL Covid-19 Mass Vaccinations In an open letter to the World Health Organization, Geert Vanden Bossche, DMV, PhD warns "all authorities, scientists and experts around the world [and the] entire world population" to put a stop to the mass vaccinations for Covid-19. Hes also conflating innate immune responses with specific immune responses induced by either infection or vaccination. This book provides a thought-provoking analysis of the complex interactions between the virus and the host immune system that underlie the evolution of the COVID-19 pandemic. Follow. The more aggressively mass vaccination progresses, the more obvious the number of cases will decline. There is a reason why a new flu vaccine is made each year: the influenza virus drifts and shifts and the vaccine needs to be reformulated to be a better match for the specific viruses that are predicted to be common during the next flu season. Its a rationale for developing reformulated booster vaccines that cover variants not well covered by the currently-used COVID-19 vaccines. The estimated length is calculated using the number of page turns on a Kindle, using settings to closely represent a physical book. Actually, its not just eerily similar, its almost exactly the same, namely that immunity from vaccines is an evolutionary selective pressure just like the evolutionary selective pressure from antibiotics to which the organism can become resistant. He invokes the discovery of variants currently in circulation that have altered portions of the spike protein the target of COVID-19 vaccine implying that these observations lead credence to his hypothesis. ON NOVEMBER 27, 2021, 7:30pm, Philippine Time, Professor Geert Vanden Bossche will be the guest speaker on the topic of "The Implications of Mass Vaccination During the Pandemic." Register now and reserve your seats. David Gorski on March 18, 2021 Tweet They do not. Vaccinologists, scientists and clinicians are blinded by the positive short-term effects in individual patents, but dont seem to bother about the disastrous consequences for global health. (I kid you not.) PDF Covid-19 Vaccination Policy Risk FAQ - WordPress.com In scenario #1, you get rid of vaccines and lockdowns and allow the virus to spread, practically unimpeded, through the population, killing more and more people and leaving many with long-term health consequences. There was a problem loading your book clubs. Since 2014, however, he has been trying (apparently unsuccessfully) to develop his so-called universal vaccine. This book brings clarity, it finally makes sense why all of these variants. The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organization He claims that keeping people in lockdown during the pandemic is not beneficial to their innate immune system, which requires exposure to viruses and bacteria to remain in tip-top shape. I reached out to Dr. Paul Offit, a paediatrician specialized in vaccines and immunology and the co-inventor of the rotavirus vaccine, to get his thoughts on whether antibiotic resistance and vaccine-associated immune escape are indeed comparable. PDF Why should current Covid-19 vaccines not be used for mass vaccination It remembers tiny invaders and fights them back with more vigour each time. After his career in Academia, Geert joined several vaccine companies (GSK Biologicals, Novartis Vaccines, Solvay Biologicals) to serve various roles in vaccine R&D as well as in late vaccine development. NK cells have increasingly been described to be endowed with the capacity to acquire immunological memory. One such claim that I hadnt yet seen is another favorite antivax claim, although admittedly its a rather niche claim in that you dont hear it too often. This is not all that impressive, given that Snopes could only identify two patent applications in Vanden Bossche's name both for "immunologic formulations" and both of these patents, records indicate, had their "applications terminated before publication.". Training is achieved by regular exposure to a myriad of environmental agents, including pathogens. And maybe, at some point, Dr. Bossche validates a new kind of vaccine that works in a completely different way and it eventually allows us to curb the pandemic. Last Monday, I provided international health organizations, including the WHO, with my analysis of the current pandemic as based on scientifically informed insights in the immune biology of Covid-19. The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organizations, institutions, and industries lacking an . Despite taking Vanden Bossches assertions extremely seriously, these high-profile alternative-media figures dont even do basic due diligence such as looking into McMillan, whos the man who interviewed Vanden Bossche, or the company McMillan is apparently affiliated with, Vejon Health. Seriously, as a vaccine expert, how is it that Dr. Vanden Bossche does not know this? If you are ready to for the truth, this book will be painful but finally make sense After three years of hearing all kinds of explanations and mixed messaging, this book finally brings clarity to what's been going on. Indeed, antibodies (Abs) produced by our own immune system can be considered self-made antiviral antibiotics, regardless of whether they are part of our innate immune system (so-called natural Abs) or elicited in response to specific pathogens (resulting in so-called acquired Abs). The vaccines are working. However, Dr. Vanden Bossches claims to have worked with the Gates Foundation, GAVI, and other vaccine-related enterprises does seem to be legitimate, which makes me wonder: Has he gone crank or is he a grifter? Exploring issues and controversies in the relationship between science and medicine. In scenario #2, we vaccinate as many people as we can and as quickly as we can. Of course, the noble purpose of these Abs is to protect us against Covid-19. He held adjunct faculty appointments at universities in Belgium and Germany. Another important counterpoint to Dr. Bossches claim is that we can simply reformulate our vaccines to match new variants of concern. Even so, concern about immune escape is one reason why Pfizer, BioNTech, and Moderna used the entire SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, rather than specific segments of it that might serve as antigens, so that the polyclonal antibody immune response generated would be broad and unlikely to be escaped with single mutationsor even multiple mutations. "There can be no doubt," Vanden Bossche asserts, "that lack of exposure due to stringent containment measures implemented as of the beginning of the pandemic has not been beneficial to keeping peoples innate immune system well trained. Biology is so complex. I will note that it is truly astounding how many statements that a supposed expert in immunology and vaccines can make that are just plain out-and-out wrong. In the case of antibiotics, its called developing antibiotic resistance; in the case of vaccines, its called immune escape. Its another step in the decades-long erasure of the fact that our sophisticated and highly effective immune systems work well and dont need any assistance from the biomedical/pharmaceutical industry. As those have stronger affinity for the pathogen (e.g., virus) and can reach high concentrations, they can quite easily outcompete our natural Abs for binding to the pathogen/virus. In my new book, The inescapable immune escape pandemic, I am sharing my insights and perspectives on how the Covid-19 pandemic continues to evolve. As the innate immune system cannot remember the pathogens it encountered (innate immunity has no so-called immunological memory), we can only continue to rely on it provided we keep it trained well enough. Immunocompromised individuals with persistent COVID-19 infections, in particular, may play a huge role in the development of variants. But if you have a full and overpowering army at your command, the invaders wont stick around for long. Unfortunately, it remains untouched by those who have the power to act. geertvandenbossche . Ultimately, most vaccines are based on a recombinant spike protein sequence. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organizations, institutions, and industries lacking an . Doctors Lounge - THE LOUNGE But if you have a vaccine that results in high levels of neutralizing antibodies, thats not a way to create variants, he continued. Some QUOTES: " mass vaccination campaigns may have a beneficial short-time effect .. but will. These assumptions come without scientific studies or data to support them and indeed are not always reasonable. As a result, I thought it worth providing this rebuttal and links to an even better rebuttal, to SBM readers in order to disseminate this information more widely. Similarly, if a new SARS-CoV-2 variant emerges and is so different that our current crop of vaccines dont match it, scientists can simply tweak their vaccines. Over the last several months, Ive listed a number of examples of this phenomenon of antivaxxers recycling hoary tropes to apply them to COVID-19 vaccines; for example, claims that vaccines kill, cause infertility, cancer, autoimmune disorders, and Alzheimers disease, and are loaded with toxins, among several others, such as the claim that they alter your DNA. Geert Vanden Bossche, PhD, DVM Independent Researcher --- Mar 2018 - Present . All of these variants were discovered prior to any widespread vaccination program. On the contrary, I can assure you that each of the current vaccines have been designed, developed and manufactured by brilliant and competent scientists. On March 6, 2021, a Belgian veterinarian named Geert Vanden Bossche published an open letter"to all authorities, scientists and experts around the world" asserting that, in his expert analysis, the current global COVID-19 vaccination program will "wipe out large parts of our human population." Geert Vanden Bossche, DMV, PhD, independent virologist and vaccine expert, . Dont you see? not enough to swiftly kill the virus when you catch it, this could allow the virus to stick around in your body for a little bit and make copies of itself. Follow Dr. Geert's work at voiceforscienceandsolidarity.org The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic : Vanden Bossche MD Phd, Geert: Amazon.es: Libros. https://www. He also points out that there is new research challenging the previous dogma that leaky vaccines always select for more virulent strains of pathogen and cannot produce herd immunity. It won't be easy for everyone to to hear their mistakes. An example of a leaky vaccine is the vaccine against Mareks disease, highly contagious and deadly viral disease of chicken that is a major problem in the poultry industry, and Dr. Vanden Bossche relies on this precedent, as Nirenberg explains: For a moment though, lets entertain the notion that the vaccines are leaky. It will not get any stronger fighting it each time. In the first two letters alone, he uses some variation of the phrase "it is reasonable to assume" at least seven times. The more extensively the later age group will be vaccinated and hence, protected, the more the virus is forced to continue causing disease in younger age groups. Speaking with McGill University's Office for Science and Society, Dr. Paul Offit, a doctor and vaccine scientist who serves as director of the Vaccine Education Center at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, explained that no matter where one is or was quarantined, you are still constantly exposed to microorganisms challenging your immune system. It is a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the intricacies of the pandemic and the impact of mass vaccination on society. And so am I. I searched PubMed for what I expected to be an extensive publication record on vaccines and foundeight publications, the most recent of which was from 1994 and none of which have anything to do with vaccines. PDF Geert Bossche: Halt All Covid-19 Mass Vaccination (Open Letter to WHO In general, you would have a hard time identifying any human vaccine that could be called leaky (though emerging findings regarding influenza vaccines give hints that there may be a leaky vaccine effect involved, given their excellent efficacy among children, who are critical vectors, I am not so convinced- though if we do grant that they are leaky, this only serves to undermine Bossches argument). Even if it were evolving resistance, once again, the answer would be to reformulate the vaccine in order to include the altered antigens, the same conclusion made when considering the possibility that B. pertussis was evolving resistance or that evolutionary drift was leading to the predominance of strains not covered by the vaccine. He also states that hes worked with GAVI: The Vaccine Alliance and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, although searching the websites, I could find no reference to him other than a report written by him and others to GAVI about progress on an Ebola vaccine. If you claim to be not antivaccine but your message is so attractive to a rabid antivaxxer and leader of the antivaccine movement like Del Bigtree that he spends an hour promoting it, you are either deluding yourself about being not antivaccine, or youre a useful idiot for the antivaccine movement, possibly both. Vanden Bossche has achieved some public attention for publiciz-ing an open letter to the World Health Orga-nization opposing vaccinations against SARS-CoV-2; his letter has been seized upon by advocates against vaccination as it seems to Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) / Twitter Explanation: Experts say there is no evidence of that happening so far. So, as we grow up, we increasingly mount pathogen-specific immunity, including highly specific Abs.